1Chris O'Donnell
Getty ImagesThe All-American, blue-eyed charmer was my first "grown-up" cinema crush.
2
Getty ImagesI first saw him in the 1993 movie The Three Musketeers. THANK GOODNESS I didn't somehow fixate on Charlie Sheen.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
3
Getty ImagesNow he plays NCIS Special Agent G. Callen in NCIS: Los Angeles. It also looks like he enjoys jumping out from behind corners and shouting, "Boo!"
4Christian Bale
Every bookish little '90s girl's heart beat apace for Christian Bale's Laurie in the 1994 Little Women movie. He was boyish, he was handsome, he liked weird girls who liked to read. Sure, in the movie and book it was Jo March, but in real life, it was ME. How much more perfect could he have been? Until...
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
5
Getty ImagesTHIS. I can't even. Cut to a few years later and Laurie is with THE WRONG SISTER. Laurie was dead to me after that.
6
Getty ImagesNow, Christian Bale is a person with a beard. (Also, Batman, etc.)
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7Tony Leung
Jet Tone ProductionIf you have ever seen the 1994 film Chungking Express, you will know that Hong Kong movie star Tony Leung is highly skilled at lasering your soul wide open with his eyes. Just look at him! That poor woman has no idea what's about to happen to her. This was all very confusing to me a young woman. So obviously, because of this, I wanted to marry him.
8
Getty ImagesHere he is six years later in In the Mood for Love, lasering Maggie Cheung's soul open. Very messy guy to be around.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
9Darren Hayes
Getty ImagesThis one might need a little extra explanation. Remember the "chick-a-cherry-cola" song? Darren Hayes was the guy singing it. I truly wanted to marry him. It was the first time my young heart knew sorrow, because I didn't know how to make a grown man love or marry me. (I was 13, so it was a good thing, in retrospect.)
10
Getty ImagesHere is Hayes with his Savage Garden bandmate Daniel Jones. Oh, Darren. He was definitely THIS kid's choice, if you know what I mean. (Ew, sorry.)
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
11
Getty ImagesMy marriage plans were put into jeopardy when Hayes came out as gay in the aughts. But he seems happy and healthy, and that's all a gal can ask for re: once-potential husbands. Now, he has a brand-new movie podcast called We Paid to See This.
12David López
...otherwise known as Alex from Ghostwriter. This Children's Television Workshop staple featured a group of Brooklyn kids who solved mysteries with the help of a ghost (naturally). In the show, Alex was a "gifted code breaker." That's hot to a pre-adolescent nerdy girl! Plus, Bambi eyes. Look at him! So adorable.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13SO CUTE. But he never solved the mystery of why we aren't married. Call me, Alex! I mean, David.
14Devon Sawa
Getty ImagesEvery strong relationship is built on seeing a cute guy on-screen for about two seconds. That's what happened when I saw Devon Sawa in Casper—he appears right at the end of the movie as the real-boy incarnation of the titular ghost. You might also remember him from 1995 friendship flick Now and Then.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
15
Getty ImagesNow he's all grown up. Where did all that beautiful hair go :(
16Elijah Wood
Getty ImagesIf you really could get married to someone just by wishing on all your heart that you were, then I'm probably married to Elijah Wood. I spent hundreds of hours watching Lord of the Rings and gazing lovingly at The Little Hobbit Who Could.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
17
Getty ImagesUnfortunately, now he is a DJ. I have just wish-divorced Elijah as of this moment, but I wish him all the best.
18
Getty ImagesAw, I love it when two of my husbands hang out together.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19Gary Barlow
Getty ImagesGive me a minute...I'm just recovering from this glorious denim vest and pant combo. This is Gary Barlow, whom you might remember from...
20
Getty Images...the British band Take That. Do you know the break-up song "Back for Good"? That's them. Other fans loved the pixie-like Mark Owen (on the left) or future bad boy Robbie Williams, but I loved Gary. He had the soul of a poet and the hair of a chia pet.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below